How to Build Your Succession Planning Team: Lessons From an $889,914 Supreme Court Case

A succession planning team is the group of advisors who make sure your plan for the business works when it’s needed. A 2024 Supreme Court case shows what happens when one piece of that plan gets missed.

Most owners are experts at running their company. Few are also experts in estate tax, insurance, contract law and business valuation, and nobody should have to be. The right team catches the gaps between those specialties before they become expensive.

That matters more now that so many owners start with a chatbot. AI tools are fast, and they’re useful for learning the vocabulary. But they haven’t read your agreement, and they don’t know whether anyone followed it. Below, we walk through the case, what has changed since, who belongs on your team, and how to use AI to show up to those meetings better prepared.

What happened in Connelly v. United States?

Brothers Michael and Thomas Connelly owned a building supply company. To keep it in the family, they signed an agreement: if one brother died, the other could buy his shares, and if he didn’t, the company would. The company bought life insurance on both brothers to pay for it.

Michael died in 2013, and the company bought back his shares. His estate valued those shares without counting the insurance money. The estate’s reasoning was that the company’s obligation to buy the shares cancelled out the payout.

The IRS disagreed. In June 2024, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously for the IRS, and the estate owed an additional $889,914 in federal estate tax.

One detail gets less attention. Their agreement called for an appraisal to set the price. They never got one. Thomas and the estate settled on a number informally.

How the Connelly plan broke down
The plan
A buy-sell agreement, funded with insurance
The brothers agreed the survivor or the company would buy a deceased brother’s shares
The company owned life insurance on both brothers to pay for it
2013
Michael dies
The company buys back his shares
The gap
The agreed process is skipped
The agreement called for an appraisal to set the price
None was done; the price was settled informally
The filing
The estate values the shares
The insurance payout is left out of the company’s value
The IRS disagrees
June 2024
The Supreme Court rules for the IRS
Unanimous decision
$889,914 in additional federal estate tax
Source: Connelly v. United States, No. 23-146 (2024).

The brothers had a plan. Where it broke down was execution and coordination.

Is the Connelly ruling still relevant in 2026?

Yes. The ruling is still the law, and Congress hasn’t changed it.

What has changed is the federal estate tax exemption. For 2026, it’s $15 million per person, with inflation adjustments starting in 2027. That means fewer estates owe federal estate tax. But many lower middle market owners hold businesses worth more than that, and a growing company can cross the line later.

We’re investment bankers, not attorneys or CPAs, so we won’t tell you how to structure your agreement. Whether Connelly affects you depends on your structure, your estate and your state, and answering that takes your advisors working together.

Can AI replace a succession planning advisor?

Ask a chatbot whether company-owned life insurance is a good way to fund a buyout, and you’ll likely get a confident, reasonable-sounding answer. It may even mention Connelly.

Here’s what it can’t do. It can’t read your agreement and notice the valuation clause nobody followed. It can’t see who owns your policies or who the beneficiaries are. It doesn’t know the size of your estate, your state’s rules, or your family’s plans. And it isn’t accountable if it’s wrong.

Use AI for what it does well: learning the terms, drafting a list of questions, or summarizing a long document before you discuss it. For a closer look at where it helps and where it falls short, see Can AI value my business? Then bring those questions to licensed professionals who are looking at your actual documents.

Who should be on your succession planning team?

  1. Investment banker. Tells you what your business is worth in today’s market, how buyers will read your structure and agreements, and what to fix now so it doesn’t cost you later. Bringing one in early means your plan is built around real market value, and you’ll know when the window to sell is open.
  2. Business attorney. Drafts and maintains your shareholder or operating agreement and buy-sell terms, and makes sure the documents match what the owners intend.
  3. Estate planning attorney. Connects the business plan to your will or trust and your family’s goals.
  4. CPA or tax advisor. Shows how a plan is taxed for the company, the owners and the estate, and keeps that current as laws change.
  5. Insurance professional. Makes sure coverage, policy ownership, and beneficiaries line up with what your agreement says should happen.
  6. Wealth manager or financial planner. Makes sure your personal finances work with or without a sale. Often the one who keeps everyone else talking.
  7. Independent valuation professional. Gives your agreement a defensible number and updates it as the business changes.

The Connelly problem sat where four of these specialties meet: insurance, contracts, valuation, and tax. Each advisor can do their piece well, and the plan can still fail if nobody looks at how the pieces fit. Pick one person to coordinate. For many owners, that’s their wealth manager or attorney.

Four specialties, one plan
Connelly sat where all four meet. Each one raises a question for your team.
Contracts
What does our agreement say happens, and does it still fit the business?
Insurance
Who owns the policies, and does that match the agreement?
Valuation
How is the price set, and has that process actually been followed?
Tax
How would this be taxed for the company, the owners and the estate?
Your advisors answer these together, using your actual documents.

How does your succession plan affect a sale?

When a buyer shows up, their diligence team reads your agreements, your insurance, and your ownership records. Clean, current documents keep diligence moving and protect your price. Surprises give the buyer leverage.

That’s why succession planning and exit planning belong in the same conversation. Our guide to succession planning for privately held companies covers the options and timeline in more detail. Our bankers regularly work alongside clients’ attorneys, CPAs, and wealth managers, and we would much rather spot an issue two years before a sale than two weeks into diligence.

It does matter who sits on your side of the table.

Where to start

Ask yourself:

  1. When did your attorney last review your buy-sell agreement, and has the business changed since?
  2. Do you know how your agreement sets the price, and has that process ever been followed?
  3. Have your attorney, CPA, and insurance advisor ever reviewed your plan together?
  4. If something happened to you next month, would your family know who to call first?

If any of those gave you pause, a joint review with your advisors is a good next step. And if you’re wondering what your business could be worth or when a sale might make sense, our team is glad to have a candid conversation.

This article is for general information only and is not legal, tax, or investment advice. Talk with your own attorney and tax advisor about your situation.

Share This Story. Choose Your Platform!

Get Started
on Your
Next Chapter

Connect Now >