Why Business Sales Fall Through and How to Prevent It
Why business sales fall through is a question most owners only ask after it happens to them. By then, the buyer has spent months inside the company, the other bidders have moved on, and the price on the table is usually lower than the one that started it all.
The handshake feels like the finish line. It isn’t. For a lower middle market company, the stretch between a signed letter of intent and the closing wire is where most value is lost, either to a dead deal or to a cut in price.
The reasons are rarely a surprise. Axial’s 2025 Dead Deal Report studied 75 signed LOIs that never closed and found that diligence findings caused nearly half of them. Below we cover when deals break, the most common deal killers, what a re-trade is, and what to do if your sale falls apart.
When do business sales fall through?
Most deals that die were already agreed in principle. The buyer and seller signed a letter of intent with a price and basic terms. Then the real work started.
An LOI almost always comes with exclusivity, also called a no-shop. For a set period, you agree not to talk to other buyers while this one checks everything. That is when the buyer’s accountants rebuild your earnings, their lawyers read your contracts, and their lender decides whether to fund the deal.
It takes a while. In Axial’s report, private equity buyers spent an average of 106 days under exclusivity before walking away. Independent sponsors averaged 129 days. That is three to four months off the market, with your other bidders gone cold, before you learn the deal is dead.
Where a sale can fall through
Before the LOI
Go to market
Buyers review the business and submit offers
LOI signed
Exclusivity begins
You stop talking to other buyers, often for three to four months
Diligence
Due diligence and QoE
Earnings rebuilt, contracts and legal reviewed, lender underwrites. The largest share of broken deals die here
Final stretch
Purchase agreement
Findings turn into price cuts, new terms, or a walkaway
Closing
Wire transfer
The deal is done only when the money moves
Timelines vary by company, buyer, and deal structure.
Why deals fall apart in due diligence
Diligence is where the buyer checks whether the business matches the story they bought into. When it doesn’t, they walk or they cut the price. In 2025 that mismatch was the top cause of broken LOIs, and it has grown every year Axial has tracked it.
Something the buyer didn’t expect. Axial’s largest category, at 25.3%, covers findings outside the financial review: legal or compliance exposure, a contract that can’t be assigned, one customer carrying too much of the revenue. In one case from the report, a buyer walked because 40% of revenue came from a single government program. Fix: run diligence on yourself before you go to market, and put known issues on the table before the LOI, when they shape the price instead of breaking the deal.
Earnings that don’t hold up. The quality of earnings review rebuilds your EBITDA line by line. Aggressive add-backs and owner expenses that aren’t clearly personal are where numbers shrink. EBITDA discrepancies caused 21.3% of broken deals in 2025, up from 10.6% in 2023. Fix: a sell-side quality of earnings report finds the gaps while you still control how they are explained.
A business that runs on the owner. If key customers, pricing, or know-how sit with you, the buyer has to price in what happens when you leave. That shows up as a lower number, a longer earnout, or a buyer who loses interest. Fix: build a team that can run the company without you, and be ready to show it. Here’s how owner dependence affects business valuation.
Something the owner kept quiet. Some owners hold back a problem they hope a buyer won’t find: a lawsuit, a tax issue, a key customer about to leave. Sometimes even their own investment banker doesn’t know. Buyers usually find it anyway, and when they do, the lost trust costs more than the issue itself. In one case from Axial’s report, undisclosed criminal charges surfaced early in diligence and ended the deal. Fix: tell your banker everything, early. We can plan around almost any problem we know about. We can’t plan around one we learn about from the buyer.
Why signed LOIs broke in 2025
Share of 75 broken deals by main reason. Diligence issues in navy.
Non-QoE diligence findings25.3%
QoE EBITDA discrepancies21.3%
Renegotiation14.7%
Seller backed out13.3%
Financing10.7%
Business underperformance8.0%
Source: Axial, Dead Deal Report: Unpacking 2025’s Broken LOIs. Remaining deals broke for other reasons.
Other deal killers when selling a business
Not every dead deal starts with a diligence finding. These cause most of the rest.
Renegotiation that goes nowhere. At 14.7%, these are deals where buyer and seller couldn’t agree on a revised price or structure. More on this under re-trades below.
The seller backs out. At 13.3%, these are owners who pulled the business or changed course mid-process. Sometimes it’s a partner who never really wanted to sell. Sometimes it’s an owner who hadn’t planned what comes next. Fix: get every owner aligned on price, terms, and life after the sale before a buyer ever sees the business.
The buyer can’t fund it. Financing caused 10.7% of broken LOIs, down from 21.3% in 2023. Fix: judge a buyer’s ability to close alongside the headline price. The highest offer is worth little if the money isn’t there.
The business slips during the sale. At 8.0%, results dropped enough during diligence that the valuation no longer held. This is the most avoidable one. A sale process takes real time, and owners who run it themselves often take their eye off the company. Fix: let an advisor run the process so you can keep running the business. See how to choose the right investment bank to sell your business.
What is a re-trade, and how do you protect against one?
A re-trade is when a buyer asks to lower the price or change the terms after the LOI is signed. Sometimes diligence turned up a real problem and the request is fair. Sometimes the buyer offered high to win exclusivity and planned to trade down all along.
Either way, the timing works against you. Your other bidders have moved on, you’ve spent months and real money on the process, and walking away means starting over. Buyers know this.
The best protection is competitive tension that exists before you sign. In practice that means:
Bring several qualified buyers to the table. A competitive process tells you what the market will pay and gives you a credible runner-up.
Disclose known issues early. A problem raised before the LOI gets priced in once. A problem found in diligence gets priced in with interest.
Tighten the LOI. A shorter exclusivity window, a clear diligence timeline, and a defined working capital target leave less room to reopen the deal.
Keep the runner-up warm. Your advisor can stay in touch with the next-best buyer without breaking the no-shop.
What happens if your business sale falls through?
It depends on how the sale was run.
If you had one buyer, you start over. The business has been off the market for months, buyers may know a deal died, and you’ll need to explain why. If results slipped while you were distracted, the next offer will reflect that.
If you ran a competitive process, a dead deal is a setback you can recover from. Your advisor goes back to the buyers who were close, often within days. We’ve closed deals this way at SDR, with a buyer who was waiting in the wings when the first one fell short.
And sometimes walking away is the right call. A buyer who re-trades once will often try again before closing, and accepting a bad deal to avoid starting over is a decision you live with for years. Your advisor’s job is to tell you plainly which situation you’re in.
Is your business ready for a buyer’s diligence?
Most of what kills a deal was in the business long before the buyer arrived. Four questions will tell you where you stand:
Would your earnings hold up if a buyer’s accountants rebuilt them today?
Does any single customer, contract, or program carry a large share of your revenue?
Are all of your owners aligned on selling, on price, and on what comes next?
SDR’s close rate is 88%. That number comes from the work done before a buyer ever sees the business: finding what diligence will find, pricing known issues early, and running a competitive process so there is always another buyer at the table.
If you’d like a candid read on how a buyer would see your company, reach out to our team.
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional
Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.