If a private equity firm makes you an offer, expect to hear about rollover equity when selling your business: you take most of the price in cash at closing and reinvest the rest alongside the new owner.
Many founders picture a sale as handing over 100% of the company and walking away within a year. That can happen. It also tends to draw fewer buyers and a lower price.
For many lower middle market companies, the larger outcome comes from a two-step exit: sell a majority now, keep a stake, and sell the rest when the new owner exits.
This is now a standard part of how middle market deals get done. GF Data’s analysis in the ACG Insights 2026 Outlook Report found that the average seller rollover rose from 14.0% of enterprise value in 2021 to 16.9% through the third quarter of 2025, as tighter credit pushed buyers to ask sellers to stay invested. Below, we cover what rollover equity is, why buyers pay more for it, how the second bite of the apple works in real numbers, and what has to be true about your business first.
Rollover equity is the part of your sale proceeds you reinvest in the business instead of taking as cash. You stay an owner, now as a minority partner to the buyer, and you usually keep running the company.
In a typical lower middle market deal with a private equity buyer, you sell most of your equity (often 70% to 80%), keep the rest, and lead the business until the investor exits, usually in 3 to 5 years. That later sale is the second step, and it pays you again.
Here is how the two paths compare:
The second path asks more of you. You keep working, and part of your wealth stays tied to the company. But it often produces a higher price on day one and a second check later.
In M&A, investors are buying the future. Most private equity firms acquire a founder-led company expecting to grow it well past its current footprint: new regions, new products, new customer types. The question in every buyer’s mind is whether that growth will happen once the deal closes.
Rolling equity answers that question in three ways.
A partnership looks less risky to a buyer than a buyout, and lower risk earns a higher multiple. In the example below, that difference is a full turn of EBITDA.
There is a benefit for you too. When most of your net worth sits inside the company, it is hard to make big bets on growth. Taking chips off the table gives you financial security and frees you to pursue the step-change ideas you may have been holding back.
The numbers below come from a transaction we completed, with identifying details removed. They show how the same business could produce very different outcomes for its founder depending on the path. Every deal is different, and past results don’t guarantee future outcomes.
The company had $22 million in revenue and $3.3 million in EBITDA, and one founder owned it.
Path 1: one-time exit. The founder could have sold 100% at about 6x EBITDA, roughly $20 million, all cash, with a one-year transition.
Path 2: two-step exit. Because the buyer saw less risk in a partnership, it paid 7x EBITDA, or $23.1 million. The founder rolled $5.8 million (25% of the deal value) and took $17.3 million in cash at closing. With the buyer also funding part of the deal with debt, that reinvestment bought the founder a 40% stake in the new company.
Over the next three years, the company grew EBITDA to $8.0 million and sold at 9x, a $72 million enterprise value. After the debt was repaid and management incentives were paid, the founder’s 40% stake returned about $20.2 million.
In this example, the founder’s second check is about 17% larger than the first, on a 25% reinvestment. Three things drive that result:
The reinvested $5.8 million returns roughly 3.5 times its value. For private equity firms, about 3x is a reasonable outcome and 5x is the target, so this example sits in a normal range rather than a best case.
A two-step exit only works if a buyer believes in two things: the business can thrive without depending on you, and you have a credible plan to grow it.
Transferable value is the value of your business whether or not you are part of it. If the company cannot run and sustain itself without the owner, its transferable value is low, and the valuation suffers. Founder-led businesses often score lower here than their owners expect.
Growth runway matters just as much. If your business has already maxed out its potential, don’t expect a maxed-out valuation. Buyers pay for the next stage, so the more concrete your plan and growth path, the more weight they give your projections.
When our bankers look at a business the way an investor will, these are the questions that come up:
Every “no” on that list is something a buyer will price in. The good news is that most of them can be fixed with time, and our guide on how to maximize the value of your business walks through where to start.
The second bite is real, but it is not guaranteed. Before you agree to roll equity, weigh the trade-offs honestly.
Treat rolled equity as upside on top of the cash you take at closing, and size that cash to cover what you and your family need. A two-step exit fits best when you still enjoy leading, believe in the growth plan, and want a partner with capital to fund it. If you are ready to step away completely, a one-time exit or a succession plan may be the better path, and that is a fine answer too.
The biggest lesson in the example above is about timing. Your true exit timeline may run 3 to 5 years past the day you sign, and planning for that longer timeline is often what earns the premium.
Four questions worth answering honestly:
If you answered yes to most of these, a two-step exit deserves a serious look.
If some gave you pause, that is worth knowing too, because most of those gaps can be closed before a sale. Either way, reach out to our team for a candid conversation about which path fits your business and your next chapter.