How to Evaluate an Offer to Buy Your Business

Learning how to evaluate an offer to buy your business starts with one idea: the number at the top of the letter is only part of the offer.

For a lower middle market company, the structure around that number, the buyer behind it and what happens to you after closing can matter as much as the price itself. A strong headline can hide weak terms. A modest one can turn into a premium outcome once other buyers get a look.

Most owners never get there. According to the Exit Planning Institute, only 20 to 30% of businesses that go to market actually sell. At SDR Ventures, 88% of the businesses we take to market close. Much of that gap comes down to how an offer gets tested before anyone signs.

Someone Wants to Buy My Business. Where Do I Start?

At SDR Ventures, we evaluate every offer through a framework we call the 3 C’s: Consideration (what you’re paid), Certainty (whether the buyer can close) and Closure (what your life and your company look like afterward).

Below, we walk through each one alongside three owners who received offers they didn’t ask for. Each thought about handling the sale on their own. Each ran a competitive process with us instead.

The 3 C’s of Evaluating an Offer
Three questions every offer has to answer, and what a competitive process delivered for three owners
Consideration
What are you actually being paid?
Done Plumbing: 118% above the first offer
Certainty
Can this buyer close?
Four Paws: 85% above the original offer
Closure
What happens after you sign?
Kenny’s Great Pies: legacy, team and role protected

Consideration: What Are You Actually Being Paid?

Consideration is the money. But the headline price and what lands in your account at closing are rarely the same number.

Most offers today come with structure attached. These three pieces show up most often:

  • Seller note. You lend the buyer part of the purchase price and get paid back over time, with interest. That money is only as safe as the business after you leave.
  • Rollover equity. You keep a stake in the company and sell it later, ideally at a higher value. It can be a second payday, or it can stay tied up for years.
  • Earnout. A payment tied to how the business performs after the sale. We treat an earnout as upside on top of a strong core price, never as part of the price you’re counting on. Scott Mitchell explains why in his Axial guest post, An Earnout Is Not Purchase Price.

Before you weigh any of it, know your number. That’s what you need from the sale to fund your next chapter after taxes and fees. Include the costs the business quietly covers today, like a company vehicle, memberships, travel and insurance. Those become yours once the check clears.

Then comes the harder question. Is the price competitive? One buyer can’t answer that. Only other buyers can.

The owners of Done Plumbing and Heating learned this firsthand. Their family-owned Denver plumbing company had been in business for 20 years when a large acquirer in the space made an unsolicited offer. They could have negotiated it on their own. Instead, they brought it to SDR, and we ran a competitive process. The final deal came in 118% above that first offer, in under six months.

“From start to finish, SDR exceeded our expectations of what an advisor could bring to the table.”

Jeromy Metz, President, Done Plumbing and Heating

Done Plumbing and Heating logo
Done Plumbing and Heating: The First Offer Wasn’t the Ceiling
Unsolicited offer from a large acquirer vs. the final price after a competitive process
Initial unsolicited offer
100
Final price after a competitive process
218
+118% in under six months
Indexed to the initial offer at 100. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Certainty: Can This Buyer Actually Close?

An offer is only worth something if it closes. Most letters of intent are non-binding, so the price in them is a starting point, not a promise.

The moment you sign one, you usually agree to stop talking to other buyers. That’s why there’s a line we repeat to every client: nothing good happens to the seller after the LOI. From then on, the buyer controls the clock, and your alternatives cool off.

Deals rarely fall apart at the offer. They fall apart after it, in diligence and renegotiation, when the seller has one buyer and no fallback. Questions worth asking before you sign anything:

  1. Can they prove the money? Ask for proof of funds or financing commitments, the same way they’ll ask for your financials.
  2. Have they closed deals like this before? A buyer’s track record tells you more than their pitch.
  3. Do they renegotiate after signing? Some buyers open high, lock you into exclusivity, then find reasons to lower the price once your other options are gone.

A single buyer has little reason to answer those questions well. Competition changes that.

When the founders of Four Paws Animal Clinic in South Carolina received an unsolicited offer, they asked SDR to review the terms before responding. Rather than test one buyer, we ran a targeted search and brought multiple offers to the table. In less than seven months, the founders had a valuation 85% above the original offer and the freedom to choose a buyer who shared their vision.

“Not only did SDR increase the terms of our transaction by several multiples, they did so knowing our strategic buyer would need to preserve the culture of our clinic for our employees, patients, and clients.”

Dr. Nori Warren, Co-Founder, Four Paws Animal Clinic

Four Paws Animal Clinic logo
Four Paws Animal Clinic: From One Offer to the Right Buyer
How a single unsolicited offer became a choice between committed buyers
STEP 1
An unsolicited offer arrives
STEP 2
The founders ask SDR to review the terms
STEP 3
SDR runs a targeted buyer search
STEP 4
Multiple offers reach the table
RESULT
The founders choose a buyer who shares their vision
85% above the original offer, in less than seven months.
Timelines and outcomes vary by company. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Closure: What Happens After You Sign?

Closure covers everything the check doesn’t. Most owners spend months on price and an afternoon on this, yet it’s the part they live with longest.

  • Your people. Who stays, on what terms, and who will lead them.
  • Your role. Advisor, employee or gone at closing. Each comes with different obligations and non-compete terms.
  • Your legacy. What happens to the brand, your customers and the community commitments you built.
  • Your life. If you’re under 65, you’ll need health coverage for your family. And the routine and identity the business gave you won’t replace themselves.

A buyer who wins on price but fails on closure can cost you more than a lower bid would have.

Kenny Burts started making pies part-time in his kitchen in 1989. Over 30 years he built Kenny’s Great Pies into a national brand run out of a 33,000-square-foot factory in Smyrna, Georgia. When he was ready to step back, he had interest from buyers. What he didn’t have was a clear read on valuation or a way to protect what mattered most to him.

With SDR running the process, Kenny sold to Kaho Partners on terms that went well beyond price. He kept ownership of the factory and a role as senior advisor. His staff stayed on with profit sharing, his brother-in-law Gary Muter became CEO, and the company’s community work continued.

“You can’t do it all yourself, and you better bring in a team that can… I was able to craft a deal I couldn’t be more happy with, and SDR’s involvement was paramount.”

Kenny Burts, Founder, Kenny’s Great Pies

Kenny’s Great Pies logo
Kenny’s Great Pies: What the Founder Kept
The terms that mattered beyond price
Ownership of the factory in Smyrna, Georgia
A senior advisor role with the company he founded
His team stayed on, with profit sharing
Family leadership, with his brother-in-law as CEO
The company’s community work continued

“It’s not just about the money, it’s the best deal.”

Kenny Burts, Founder, Kenny’s Great Pies

Is This a Good Offer for My Business?

Before you respond to any offer, run it through these five questions:

  1. Do I know what my business is worth today, based on current deals in my industry?
  2. Do I know my number, and does this offer clear it after taxes, fees and structure?
  3. Has this buyer shown proof they can close on these terms?
  4. Do I know what happens to my employees, my role and my legacy after closing?
  5. Would I still accept this offer if I knew another buyer would pay more?

If you can’t answer yes to all five, you’re not ready to respond yet. That’s normal, and it’s fixable.

If the offer on your desk is one you didn’t ask for, start with our guide on how to respond to an unsolicited offer for your business. If you’d like a second set of eyes on any offer, reach out to our team for a candid conversation about what we see.

Share This Story. Choose Your Platform!

Get Started
on Your
Next Chapter

Connect Now >